Tie Sosnowski
President (Foreign Investors Council)
2010-06-01
Could you tell us more about the structure of the Foreign Investors Council?
It was established in 2006 by David King, with a grant from USAID. They didn’t provide any money but just helped us to start. Today we have over 30 members, who have invested over 4 billion Euros in the country and have over 10,000 employees. Although 30 investors doesn’t sound like a lot, they are the key investors in the country. Also remember that Bosnia is very small, with a population of just 4 million people.
Was it based on your personal initiative that you started the council?
It was an initiative by David King with about five or six prominent investors in the country, who agreed that they wanted to participate. The FIC is completely independent, with 100% of funds coming from membership fees. We do not receive any money from the government or outside institutions.
What relationship do you have with the the different chambers of commerce in Bosnia and Herzegovina?
We have no official ties with these institutions, but we do have the Cooperation Council, which is held quarterly. This gathers economic councilors from all the embassies and other government institutions. This is a time when we can share our different economic views on the country. We also hold forums and roundtable discussions every month in which we meet with the President or Prime Minister of the country, or an institution like the Foreign Trade Chamber. But it is very important that we are not officially connected with the government. This way we can be independent and share our independent views on how we think policies should change. I also want to add that we put out a lot of information, firstly on our website. We hope to provide a place where companies can go and find out all the information on how to register, information about taxes, etc. It is also a place they can go to talk to other companies. But the most important product we put out is our White Book, which we issue once a year. For example, in the first year we issued the White Book, we select three areas in the economic sector we thought the government could change. In 2009 we selected eight areas, in the least political way possible. We tried to choose items that could be beneficial for both local and foreign investors, and that all the political parties could agree on. We have had some modest achievements in the past year, and we’re still trying to promote some other items on the agenda.
Are you also working in Republika Srpska?
Yes, in fact in our next board meeting involve a presentation in Banja Luka. Every two or three board meetings are in Banja Luka.
We have noticed that people in the business community here have become more frustrated in the last three years than in the previous years. Do you have any explanation for this trend?
I think all the FIC members, as well as the general business community would agree with this. Since the Dayton Accords in 1995, this is the worst time it’s been because the political rhetoric has been too high. Everyone knows that investors go where there is security, predictability, and where you can make money. Here it has been very difficult because the foundation has not been set for investors. Although the political situation has been difficult, I always try to stress the positive. There is a huge potential here. You don’t have the massive growth here that you have in other countries, but I do think Bosnia and Herzegovina will see this massive growth in the future. So there is a big upside on your investment. Yes, there is risk, but there is also high reward. If you understand that and understand the local situation, then I think you can manage the risk and attain those high rewards. Secondly, there is an extremely high skill level here considering the low wages, as opposed to other countries. This has not yet been tapped, so it is something companies could absolutely take advantage of. Also, natural resources are extremely abundant here. The energy and tourism sectors have not been tapped. Eco-tourism is also a huge growth opportunity. For example, you fly into Sarajevo and you are 15 minutes away from two huge Olympic skiing mountains. You are also only a couple hours from the coast. We’re trying to push the government to make these changes in a positive way.
How many people work for the FIC?
Bojana Škrobić Omerović is our executive director and all the rest are volunteers. For example, we have the head of PricewaterhouseCoopers, the country director for EBRD (European Bank for Reconstruction and Development), the head of Heidelberg Cement, the director of Arcelor Mittal, and the chairs of Hypo Alpe Adria and Raiffeisen banks are on the board as well. So we have some very influential people. But also remember that Bosnia does not have so many foreign investors. I see that as a positive thing because now is the time to enter the Bosnian market and get those high returns. While in Western Europe you may get an 8 or 9% return, here you can get a 14 or 15% return on a reasonable investment.
How long does it take to register a company in Bosnia and Herzegovina?
It takes about three months, although it used to take about a year. If the government continues to make reforms, I hope it will be about two to four weeks.
Do you also work with the American Chamber of Commerce?
Yes, I am on the board of the Chamber. Both the Chamber and the FIC share almost all ideas on what we think should change in Bosnia and Herzegovina.
We have not found too many American investors in this country. Is this mainly due to the political situation of the country or are their other reasons?
I think for all investors—not only Americans—due to the conflict in the 90’s, investors associate Bosnia and Herzegovina with that period rather than all the positive aspects of the country. Also, there are some obstructions and difficulties when you come here, but the government is working on improving those.
Have you tried investing in other countries in the region?
Aside from Bosnia and Herzegovina, my company, Triland, has not invested anywhere else in the former Yugoslavia.
From a personal perspective, what attracted you to Bosnia and Herzegovina?
I think the challenge of coming here and the opportunity of creating something were what drew me here. In my company, and I think I can speak for the Board as well, we’re trying to show that companies can provide something positive for their employees and for the community. In my company, what we have tried to do with the Alta Shopping Center is provide a shopping center that can bring together the community and make people feel safe and proud. In Dallas, Texas, for example, we have thousands of malls, so I wanted to make a difference and create something here that the people of Sarajevo did not have before.
What keeps you motivated despite the pessimism in the business community?
I always believe the glass is half full. We have to support the positive people here, and there are so many I could name. I think that the U.S. government and the EU are going to support the people and government officials here who want to foster good growth in the country. I believe that Bosnia and Herzegovina will be a part of the EU and there is no other path. If you look on a map, you can see it has to be a part of the EU. If you ask the population, they want to be a part of the EU. It is a natural progression, so that is why I am here. It would be incorrect for me to say there are no problems, but that is my message to investors: there are problems, but if you know how to manage them with good planning and resources, and with good local support, then you can succeed here and see the rewards.
Do you think foreign investment is the only way forward for this country?
It is the only way forward for any country. In a global environment, how can America move forward without China, France, or the UK? It is impossible for smaller economies like Bosnia and Herzegovina to survive without foreign investments. In order to promote these investments, the political situation must continue to improve. In order to encourage this, we are trying to support the Office of the High Representative and Ambassador Charles English, and help the country further integrate with EU standards and promote a greater and stronger democracy, as well as a united Bosnia and Herzegovina. There are of course a few politicians that are there for themselves. But that is why we are stressing to those politicians that they need to change, or the population needs to vote for politicians who can move the country towards the EU.
Could you give three pieces of advice to a foreign investor who may be interested in Bosnia and Herzegovina?
Plan well, have patience, and be part of the FIC.
Since December 2006, have you been contacted by foreign companies that wanted to invest in this country?
Yes, all the time, although the global economic crisis has slowed things down a bit. Just this year we have seen foreign investors starting to return to Bosnia and Herzegovina but last year was extremely slow. In 2007 and early 2008 there was a great deal of interest. I’ve been here since 1995, so I can say that end at the end of 2005 the economy really started to grow, but with the economic crisis and the recent so-called political crisis in the past year, it has slowed. But I would say that by the end of 2010, early 2011, we will start to see some changes. To summarize, there are definitely political issues here. But the question is: what is the country going to do if it doesn’t go to the EU? What are its alternatives? To me, there are no alternatives. If there are, though, I would like to hear the alternatives from the politicians for creating a stronger Bosnia and Herzegovina. In addition, the government will need to recognize the FIC as a current and future partner in implementing ways to speed up the business environment in Bosnia and Herzegovina.
Regarding the economy, what is your focus for the end of 2010 and beginning of 2011?
It is getting the media involved and making it easier to do business. It is also making it more attractive for foreigners to come here. The FIC believes that the more we support foreign investment as well as local investment, the economy will grow. I believe in growing the pie bigger, not carving up the pie. I want everyone to benefit. As I am part of the real estate business, last year we supported tax reform, business registration and some other legal procedures that did not benefit the biggest companies in the country, but it did help smaller businesses. In the Brčko District, there was a double taxation issue, so we helped to draft a law to address that problem. That is something that the FIC directly influenced, because this double taxation was harming the banks and other companies doing business in that area. For example, I wouldn’t have wanted to buy real estate in the Brčko District if I was going to be taxed twice. So the eight reforms we are focusing on are beneficial for foreign investors—large and small—as well as local investors.
What kind of relationship do you have with the universities, for example, the University of Sarajevo, which has about 45,000 students waiting for a job?
We do not have any specific plans related to the universities. Our goal is to support foreign investors coming here and lobby for those reforms. We feel that if we can get more foreign business in Bosnia and Herzegovina, then that will be best for the university system. Two years ago, we also had a discussion with the Ministry of Education regarding diploma recognitions. We were actively involved with this issue, and while it still is a problem, it has improved.
What are the main differences between the American and Bosnian perspectives?
Bosnians may be a little more laid-back in the planning of business, so maybe there is not as much detailed work. But I think both sides can learn a lot from each other.
Interview conducted by Anko Ordoñez and Julie Bruneau