Bosnia: Interview with Kenan Crnkić

Kenan Crnkić

General Manager (PRIZMA Microcredit Foundation)

2010-05-27
Kenan Crnkić
PRIZMA started its activities in Bosnia and Herzegovina in 1997 with strong support from the U.S. Government. Could you describe the main steps in the evolution of PRIZMA?

Nowadays PRIZMA is one of the leading microfinance institution in Bosnia and Herzegovina, assisting small businesses and the wider population, by providing long-term access to quality financial services trough crediting entrepreneurship, agriculture, basic needs and sustainable livelihood. In addition to Headquarter located in Sarajevo, PRIZMA currently has three decentralized regional centers with more than 40 branches all over the country, from which over 250 staff members serve clients in more than 100 low-income municipalities across entire territory of Bosnia and Herzegovina. PRIZMA is streaming towards fusion of financial and development objectives, as well as contributing in positive changes in human lives, and by enhancing its own organizational sustainability to serve population of Bosnia and Herzegovina on long-term basis. During its 12 years of successful existence PRIZMA disbursed about 300.000 loans in the amount of KM 450 millions.
In the initial phase, PRIZMA was beneficiary of multiple grants from the world's leading agencies that were operational in Bosnia and Herzegovina, such as USAID, UNDP, BPRM and the World Bank. PRIZMA with its successful operations, in a relatively short time achieved a full self-sustainability and was funded by socially responsible investors, and later by the commercial institutions on the entirely market basis. Nowadays, being particularly proud, we point out that a large number of domestic and international institutions placed their confidence to PRIZMA, through the large number of credit lines of which some of them were in the value of several million. PRIZMA gained the confidence from the leading microfinance and commercial investors, as one of the few financial institutions who received Award for the high level of transparency in financial reporting and operations from the World Bank and CGAP's (Consulting Group to Assist the Poor) three years in a row. This year, according to the ranking of the microfinance institutions throughout the world, made by MIX MARKET (Microfinance Information Exchange) from Washington, USA, the leading global business provider dedicated to strengthening and promoting of the microfinance sector, the Microcredit Foundation PRIZMA was ranked among the best 50 microfinance institutions in the world.

Basically, microfinance institutions are not social or humanitarian organizations. They are aiming actually to be treated as typical financial institutions with a social objective. They are not just focused on the profit but also on changing people lives, taking people out of the poverty and in particular investing, financing and supporting entrepreneurship, as the most elegant way to solve the problem of unemployment. One of the most important things is to mention that microfinance is a very powerful tool. The interest in microfinance grew in 2005 with the United Nations Year of Microfinance and then later when Mohammad Yunus received the Nobel Peace Prize for his microfinance organization and community development bank. It is one of the most rapidly growing industries in the world.



Based on your experience, what were the main reasons why only women could get a loan from PRIZMA during these 10 years?

There are two reasons. Usually, at that time men were in charge of everything so we wanted to give power to women by giving them access to finance which was the major obstacle for starting a business. And the second reason why we used to work exclusively with women was that generally speaking, they pay back the loans better.



It is a risky activity…

Exactly, it is risky but we have had a lot of success. As I mentioned before in our 12 years of existence, we have been concentrated on providing quality financial services in four different areas: entrepreneurship, farming, housing and basic needs. In 12 years, we have disbursed over 300,000 loans for a total amount of 450 million KM (more than 300 million USD). The repayment rate has  always been around 95 and 96% which is a result even better than in banks. In more than 80% of the cases we gave loans without collaterals. We need people with good character that really want to take themselves out of the poverty, that want to improve their lives, employ other people. We support these people not only with money but also with technical assistance, education, business development services, etc.

From an investment perspective, PRIZMA has been among the leaders in the world given the fact that the Microfinance Information Exchange Market has been ranking us among the fifty best microfinance institutions in the world. We have been the only one from the region ranked there. Based on six or seven criteria, this ranking is not about who is the biggest but who is the best. We have obtained great results for 12 consecutive years. Our financial results are higher than in any other financial institution and at the same time we are helping the development of entrepreneurships projects. One of the main consequences of this success is that socially responsible investors are willing to invest in us, as well as some of the biggest comercial players in the world.
Currently, our investors are the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development—which is one of the most powerful investors in the world—Deutsche Bank, Crédit Suisse, many specialized funds like the Developing World Markets from the United States, Blue Orchard Finance and Responsibility from Switzerland, Triodos Doen, Oikocredit and Triple Jump from Netherlands and also some development agencies like ICO (Instituto de Crédito Oficial) from Spain, IFAD (International Fund for Agricultural Development) from the United Nations, etc. These investors are supporting us mainly for two reasons. First of all, they understand that through microfinance they can help the development of the society. The second reason is that microfinance can also be a good business.



How important for PRIZMA is the education of its employees?

In 12 years we invested a lot in the growth of the company but also in its own development. In that sense, our employees are extremely well-educated. We are the youngest team in the region in this field. In my case, I was the youngest CEO in the region. In addition, we won the UN award for best business practices and also, in accordance wit research provided by leading web portal for employment in BiH www.posao.ba, Microcredit foundation Prizma has been declared as one of the most attractive employers in Bosnia and Herzegovina in 2008 and 2010. We are very proud of these recognitions.



Since your organization has grown so much, are you willing to become a for-profit organization?

A new law has been adopted in that sense in Bosnia and Herzegovina. This law enables us to become a for-profit organization and give our clients more than just a loan. What is interesting for us is to also provide them with micro insurance, micro remittances, micro leasing, credit cards, etc. From 2004 to 2009, we grew 500%. In these five years, our capital increased by 3,000% and our assets by around 2,700%. In 2004, we were at the 10th or 11th place concerning market share and nowadays we are one of the top leaders in the local market. From a social institution we are becoming a financial institution. We have received a rating of “A-” from Planet Rating which is the specialized microfinance rating agency. We are currently negotiating with one of the most known mainstreamrating agency, in order to establish a rating for PRIZMA. We would be the first microfinance institution to do it. In addition, external audit statements have been done by Pricewaterhouse Coopers, Deloitte and KPMG.

Regarding the question you asked, our new strategy, established one and a half years ago, has five guidelines. The first guideline: we will never move out of the so called “down market” niche of microfinance. It does not matter what we will be in the future, a bank or a financial holding—we will always work with this market segment. There is an important segment of people that cannot have access to the traditional banking system. The second guideline of our strategy: we offer microfinance and not microcredit. We have to provide something else than loans, meaning micro insurance, credit cards, etc. Banks cannot access rural areas. Since we are already present there, we want to bring the remittances to people’s doors. Several hundred thousand Bosnians live in the USA for example and they send remittances every month. Unfortunately, the legal environment is still not very defined. Laws do not say that you can do something and at the same time they do not say that you can’t. That is the worst scenario for a transparent institution. PRIZMA is being very prudent and we will wait for a clear signal from the supervision body that we can start providing these mentioned services. Our third guideline consists of transforming our institution into a for-profit organization in order to have access to equity investors. Currently, we are receiving loans that we renegotiate every year or every two years with our investors, which is a very short term. There are investors working with us for five years—we know them, they know us. They want to take a position based on the equity.  That would help us to grow and to have access to a greater population as well. The fourth guideline of PRIZMA’s strategy refers to the regional expansion. Bosnia and Herzegovina is a small country, despite the fact that we are working very well here, there is a great market in Serbia which is very undeveloped in terms of lending. Only banks are present there. There are no cooperatives or micro finance institutions. Even people from Serbia have been coming to Bosnia and Herzegovina asking us for a loan. Of course, we cannot disburse them but we cannot avoid the fact that there is a demand in Serbia. The last guideline of our strategy is mainly focused on sustainable growth. We need to invest in good people, in technical assistance, in knowledge and in the infrastructure.



PRIZMA has around 50,000 active clients. How many clients do you expect to have by the end of this current year?

We estimate that this year is not a year of huge growth. Bosnia and Herzegovina has been quite affected by the global crisis. People have more problems than ever to repay their loans to the banks and different institutions. In addition, 2010 is an election year in the country. We never expect to grow so much during these kinds of moments; we have learnt some lessons from the last 12 years. At the same time, we have been growing a lot and now we want to consolidate more. This is a year in which we are classifying our assets. Currently, PRIZMA has 24 investors around the world that we have to consolidate. We also have to find new investors as well. They are many strong players that have expressed their interest in the microfinance sector. In that sense, we would have largest amount of investments and we could become more competitive in the market. Just to sum up, for the year we expect to grow between 7 and 10% which is almost nothing compared to the 100 to 150% growth in previous years.  PRIZMA might have been the only microfinance institution in this country to end up with positive net results in 2009. So this year we are concentrating on remaining stable.



Are you developing any projects that you would like to highlight?

This year we will establish the PRIZMA Academy. It will be an independent educational institution with the aim of giving educational support to our clients. In the long term, we would like to establish our own university. We have a very good connection with Sarajevo Graduate School of Business which offers the only accredited American MBA in the region. I personally did this MBA program. Our idea is to establish a bachelors degree that would be recognized in Bosnia and Herzegovina and the American institutions. We want to invest in education because it is a sector managed too much at the state level, the quality is not high enough and the degrees are not recognized throughout the world. It will be great to offer a high quality education, and PRIZMA, jointly with an American institution, could do this in the future.



The economy of Bosnia and Herzegovina has been constantly growing in recent years but the global situation in 2009 has affected its development. At the same time, the political situation does not seem to help in its recovery. How do you see the evolution of Bosnia and Herzegovina in the next five years?

I think that currently, in Bosnia and Herzegovina, people are completely depressed because they see no progress. If the visa liberation happens this year, it would be good for Bosnians and would show them that we are really on the road to Europe. At the same time, 2010 is an election year but at this moment we cannot predict which parties will win. However, Bosnia and Herzegovina has a stable currency, and that is a big advantage compared to other countries in the region. Our country does not look that promising right now but this is actually when you can find the best investment opportunities. The return on investment in Bosnia and Herzegovina is much higher than in a European Union country. Geographically, the country is well positioned. We have young people prepared to work.  I do not see a big improvement of the general situation this year but in the long term, Bosnia and Herzegovina has a lot to offer.



In your opinion, is it recommendable for a foreign investor to start a Greenfield investment in Bosnia and Herzegovina?

What really makes sense is to invest together with a local institution that shares the same mindset. When investors come to PRIZMA, they see a role model financial institution. This is why we were among the first one in BiH to work with Pricewaterhouse Coopers. PRIZMA is very American-oriented in the sense that we are used to work based on Western standards and we share similar mentalities. That is perhaps the main difference between PRIZMA and other microfinance institutions.



Could you sum up your management style in one sentence?

I will quote a sentence from Peter Druker: “Management is doing things right; leadership is doing the right things.”  I am trying to figure out what the right things are and everything else is up to the management. I am very confident in my management and all other people at PRIZMA. I consider them being the best and I’m proud to work with them such people in developing this great institution as well as communities and countries we work at.



Interview conducted by Anko Ordoñez and Julie Bruneau.