Bosnia: Interview with Kemal Kozarić
Kemal Kozarić
Governor (Central Bank of Bosnia and Herzegovina)
2010-03-03
In 2004, Bosnia and Herzegovina had a “B3” credit rating assigned by Moody’s Investors Service. Two years later, in 2006, the credit system received a “B2”, and on December 2009, Standard & Poor's Rating Services confirmed a 'B+' credit rating with stable outlook for Bosnia and Herzegovina. In your opinion, what role has the Central Bank played in the improvement of the monetary and financial stability of the country?
As for the credit rating in 2009, we have two assignments, one from Standard & Poor and the other one from Moody. As a fiscal agent of the State, we are actually making the logistical and technical preparations necessary for the whole mission of the rating assignments in the country. We still have a B2 rating; this means a positive outlook for the country. Bearing in mind the circumstances and situation related to the global economic crisis, as well as the macroeconomic picture in the surrounding area and in Bosnia and Herzegovina, I believe this is a good result. Of course, we are aware that this credit rating is still not that attractive for foreign direct investments. But considering the whole situation, it is good that our credit rating is not lower than in the pre-crisis period. The stability of the financial sector, the monetary stability, a relatively small external public debt as well as the regular servicing of the external public debt are the most important reasons why this credit rating is still at the same level as it used to be last year.
That said, the Progress Report done by the European Commission on B&H in 2009 is negative and the grade of the Economic-Fiscal Program (EFP) is not high either. Why has the country received an extremely low grade from the European Commission – a grade significantly lower than the one received in 2008?
This is again a consequence of the influence of the political world on the whole image of Bosnia and Herzegovina and, most importantly, it is the result of constitutional reforms which were impeded by political hindrance. Limitations relating to visa arrangements are another factor as well; it’s only last month that we succeeded to abolish those visa limitations for our citizens.
The official currency of Bosnia and Herzegovina is the Konvertible Mark which is fixed to the Euro. On one side, this gives stability to the monetary system, but on the other side, it does not allow the Central Bank to devaluate the currency in order to increase the country’s exports. In your opinion, how important is it to keep your currency fixed to the Euro?
Monetary policy in this country is defined by the law on the Central Bank, where we use the regime of the currency board. This is a conservative model, which does not give the Central Bank too many instruments or tools to play around with. There is a fixed rate back to the Euro which is defined by the law, but on the other hand, each KM in circulation also has a fixed rate back to the Euro. This gives security to both corporate and economic subjects, and also to the population, as it allows citizens to save, purchase or exchange KM and Euro in commercial banks. On the other hand, we are not allowed to give credits to the State nor to commercial banks. The instrument most used in our power is the “required reserves”. The aim of this measure is to keep the banking sector liquid and to make sure that bank deposits are protected from any eventual loss. Our fixed currency gives even more security for anybody that is investing in the country. Investment, profit and salaries will not devaluate. The example of a neighboring country like Serbia shows us how a 20% devaluation of the Dinar also affected profits down by 20%, leading to an increase in credit rates by another 20%. In the case of Bosnia and Herzegovina, we have what we call the “monetary certainty stability”.
With no possible devaluation of your currency, what instruments does the Central Bank have in order to resolve the effects of the crisis?
The most important fact is that confidence in the banking sector remains at a satisfactory level. In addition, in line with our “required reserves” policy which is checked on a daily basis, we make sure that none of the commercial banks are non-liquid. All commercial banks respond to the demands of their customers and these customers keep using the banking channels. After the bankruptcy of Lehman Brothers, 400 million Euros were withdrawn in Bosnia and Herzegovina. The Central Bank therefore has an important role to play in our country’s monetary system, because we take care of the credibility and stability of the banking sector, which is very important for any economy.
And no bank had to close during the crisis…
No one had to close indeed.
Can you confirm that capitalization in this country stands at 16% at the moment?
Yes, it does. The European standard is 12% and in the US it is 8%. Here we have 16% of capitalization in the banking sector. Capitalization of commercial banks here is quite satisfactory.
What solutions would you suggest in order to facilitate the population’s access to a credit bank in BH?
Despite of the crisis that is still affecting the country, we do try to encourage banks to continue crediting and giving loans. But banks here, like everywhere in the world, have become more restrictive and more cautious in risk management, and today it is more difficult to get a credit than it was a year ago. On the other hand, commercial banks are complaining that they do not receive enough good quality programs, which is partly true. The citizens’ debt is 850 Euros per capita. This is quite a high level of debt. The population is quite exhausted in that sense.
On March 1, 2010, CBBH will start a project of direct cooperation with the European Central Bank and the Euro system partner banks, all financed by the EU pre-accession assistance instruments. What concrete results would you like to achieve before the end of 2010?
We will start this important project in March with the European Central Bank. Together with the European Central Bank, we selected several areas to work on in order to prepare the Central Bank of Bosnia and Herzegovina to adopt European standards before the country became a candidate for EU membership. Some areas selected included, for example, financial stability reporting, statistics, IT, internal auditing areas, foreign currency reserves management… But besides that, it is very important for us to have a closer cooperation with the European Central Bank. We are on the way to celebrate a conference on 25th of February in Hotel Europa in Sarajevo, where, together with the Bundesbank of Germany and the National Czech Bank, through the European Central Bank and the European Commission, we will complete a project on human resources management in the Central Bank of Bosnia and Herzegovina. We are investing a lot in training our employees and in the improvement of our capacity building. We are trying to implement European standards in our institution and, according to foreign observers; we are seen as a Central Bank which is small but doing quite well in adopting the surrounding standards in general.
Is there any investment opportunity for American and European companies in the financial sector of Bosnia and Herzegovina?
Unfortunately, American investors are not well represented here and they never have. Concerning the banking sector, our market is too small for American companies. However, the banking sector has proved to be a good opportunity for foreign direct investment. The biggest banks present in our country are Austrian, Italian and Slovenian, and they are playing a major role in the banking sector of Bosnia and Herzegovina. We did not receive a request from worldwide banks such as City Bank for example. It may sound strange but the reason is that we are a small market.
Bosnia and Herzegovina is a small market in itself but it is located within a growing region which has 35 million consumers. This can change the usual market size perception somewhat, can it not?
It is not too late to invest in the banking sector. There are some small banks which are looking for merger or acquisition. These are good opportunities for American investors willing to invest here. And you are right, we have to see our country within a region which has great potential.
If you were the journalist here today, what would you ask the Governor of BH Central Bank?
I would ask: “What is the independent role of the Central Bank in Bosnia and Herzegovina since it is very difficult to be independent and impartial in this country?” This definitely is an important issue. It is very difficult to speak about this institution where my colleagues and I work. However, we are known as one of the most successful institutions in Bosnia and Herzegovina. We are the owners of a paying system which is supporting each payment transaction and change in any point of Bosnia and Herzegovina’s territory. Each KM issued in the country is issued and comes out from this Central Bank. All the reserves are here. All commercial banks are meeting the required reserves in our institution. We have our main units in Banja Luka, Mostar, Sarajevo, Brčko and Pale. We are proud to be the institution of all citizens of the country. Six months ago, I was reassigned for a second mandate which was seen as something impossible to achieve. I do not belong to any political party and neither do any of my colleagues or associates at management level. Our professional approach to all the issues we have on our agenda has made it possible for this institution to remain reputable and to have a positive connotation in people’s mind, as well as a positive effect on the country. We are independent concerning both profits and staff selection. Last year we had a profit of 100 million and we have achieved 60 million Euros this year.
Tell us more about yourself. What are you most proud of in your career?
In the first six years following the creation of the Central Bank of Bosnia and Herzegovina, the Governor was a foreigner. At that time, I was one of the Vice Governors. When I became the Governor, many people thought that this institution would never continue the way it started. And many people thought that the Central Bank would fall under the influence of politicians. But we did not do that. From a personal point of view, I reached my biggest achievement last year, when I completed my PHD. I also started teaching at the Faculty of Economics in Sarajevo.